Music is not science

We are sure Sir Paul McCartney enjoys his celebrity status. It’s a shame that he continues to abuse it to campaign against the use of animals in research. Whilst McCartney may have been a great musician, that does not make him a great scientist. His statement that animal research is “a holdover from the dark age of medical science” is clearly not based on any particular expertise or insight.

McCartney had previously recognised that some animal testing is necessary, but seems to have subsequently gone back on that position.

What irritates us about this whole affair is that his wife, Heather Mills McCartney, an amputee, has just undergone major and complicated surgery called “revision amputation” which involves re-attaching muscle tissue to her bone. The procedure was developed and refined in animal models.

Sir Paul’s first wife received extensive treatment for breast cancer which was developed and then tested at least partly in animals. Apparently she was not told that animals were involved in developing her medicines because no one wanted to upset her. What is Sir Paul playing at?

Comments

    Page 1 of 1 pages of comments • Follow through:
  1. Maybe having Macca’s missus as an enemy is no bad thing. Here’s what Sam Wollaston, The Guardian’s TV reviewer, said about The McCartneys Versus the Fur Trade on BBC1 last night. 

    "The footage of what happens to the cats and dogs in China is really awful, and all the people involved in that should obviously be executed immediately. But there’s also something really awful about Heather Mills McCartney. I’m beginning to wonder if her involvement is counterproductive: that the reason fur has recently become so fashionable again, and why Naomi’s gone back to it after once famously preferring to go naked, is that it’s a two-finger salute by fur enthusiasts to HMMcC. Stop shouting at us, and whining, and harassing us in the street. Just because you’re Macca’s missus, you think people should listen. What’s this mink coat got to do with Czech cats or Chinese dogs anyway?"
    Posted by Zebedee / April 20, 2006 | Thursday | 08:36 PM |
  2. Page 1 of 1 pages of comments • Follow through:

Only registered users can comment

Please use the login form in the left column.

Next entry: I'm Spartacus - and you?

Previous entry: The tide is turning

<< Back to main